Judge Judy Wednesday will be back next week, as I needed to post this review of Twin Peaks: The Second Season. It'll be released next week.
Twin Peaks: The Second Season (1990-1991)
Rating: 4.5 stars out of 5.0 stars
Well it only took six years and a change in rights from one company to another, but finally we have the release of the second and final season of Twin Peaks. The story of the small, quirky Washington town is finally complete (well mostly) thanks to Paramount Home Entertainment under their CBS DVD banner.
The second season of Twin Peaks was hotly anticipated when it premiered in the fall of 1990. The first season had been a runaway success and everyone was talking about it. By the end of the show's run however, it had become one of the lowest rated shows on television.
So what killed Twin Peaks' popularity just as quickly as it rose mere months earlier? Despite the changes in the show and the shift towards more supernatural elements, in my mind the biggest culprit was the American Broadcasting Company itself.
The show's first season originally aired on ABC on Thursday nights. Peaks was always a watercooler-type show, and one of the things that helped it build public awareness was that people would come to work on Friday and basically say to their co-workers "Did you see Twin Peaks last night? What the hell?!?" People who didn't see it became intrigued, and checked it out for themselves. They too found themselves hooked.
Well the ABC programming pinheads, in all their brilliance, decided that if it ain't broke they need to fix it. So the show was moved from Thursdays to Saturdays, along with other critically acclaimed shows such as China Beach.
Nothing thrives on Saturdays. Nothing. People go out on Saturdays. Lynch once said in an interview on NBC's Late Night with David Letterman that Peaks people are party people, and therefore aren't home on Saturdays to watch the show. As a result of ABC's complete ineptitude, both China Beach and Twin Peaks did not survive that season.
The dopes even devised an insipid marketing campaign for this equally
insipid move. The ads featured a room of executives nervous for their
jobs because they were moving their best shows to the television
wasteland, and they asked us to find it in our hearts to stay home and
watch so their jobs could be saved.
To be fair, creatively the show declined as well, which also helped kill it. Some of it was unavoidable. Certain plotlines along the way had to be jettisoned for whatever reason, and the writers were left scrambling at the last minute to find new ideas to fill the time.
Some individual episode thoughts:
Episode 8: In this, the two-hour second season premiere directed by David Lynch, we find out who killed Laura Palmer. Yep, that's how the episode ends, in one of the creepiest scenes I've ever seen on network television. Of course it's not exactly what it appears to be though...
Episode 9: Also directed by David Lynch, this episode sets up the Windom Earle subplot that'll drive the latter half of the season. It's a shame that something that was set up so early would wind up being so rushed. Later, it's alluded to that aliens might be involved in the town's shenanigans. That might have lost a few viewers right there. Then, immediately following the possible aliens, James, Donna and Maddy have some sort of bizarro sing-along which is without a doubt the goofiest scene in Peaks history. And that's saying something.
Episode 10: The 180 degree turn Miguel Ferrer's character takes here still baffles me, and his character sadly never recovers.
Episodes 11-13: Another problem that would help seal the fate of the series was Lynch's intention to never truly solve the mystery
of Laura Palmer's murder, hoping instead that the quirkiness of the
show would be enough to keep bringing people back week after week. Episodes 11-13 are proof that this wasn't the best idea. The murder case is barely even mentioned over these three hours, and what we were given in its place wasn't a compelling enough substitute. Even I was close to bailing on this show.
In episode 12,
Cooper reveals that he's been in town for 12 days, which blew my mind
when I first heard it. I'd been watching this show for over a year and only
12 days had gone by? Crazy. Episode 13 continues the mediocre
nothingness, although it does mark the first of David Lynch's great
guest-starring appearances as Cooper's hard of hearing boss. Things then pick WAY up
during the finale.
Episode 14: Game on folks. This Lynch directed episode promised to reveal the true killer of Laura Palmer and boy howdy, does it ever do that in just about the most disturbing way possible. This might be the single greatest episode of television I've ever seen.
Episode 15: This episode used to bug me a bit, because it seemed like worthless filler between the reveal and the resolution. But I've come to enjoy it a great deal, as we get to see an episode just like any other, but instead knowing what we now know. It's like a fresh new perspective. One episode of it was the right choice. Any more than that would have angered even more people.
Episode 16: This is the resolution to Laura Palmer's murder case. Brilliantly acted (save for one totally off the wall speech by Cooper near the end), although it's a bit of a letdown after the high point of the reveal. But the problem is... now what?
Episode 17: Now what, indeed. This episode takes place three days after the previous one, and if you look at it close enough you can actually see wheels spinning. They needed to come out of the gate full force with this episode with something as compelling as Laura's murder to keep people hooked, and instead there's just nothing. The storyline with Cooper's insane former partner Windom Earle, who has been mentioned a few times by this point, should have leapt to the forefront.
Episodes 18-20: Technically the show was a soap opera, but up until now it managed
to avoid most soap cliches and stayed unique enough to stand out. Sadly episode 18 introduces a far too lengthy subplot involving James leaving town and ending up in some sort of love
triangle, murder pact. It's straight out of Knots Landing or Falcon
Crest, and it flat out sucks. David Duchovny's presence as a cross-dressing DEA agent helps soften the blow however. A very young Molly Shannon has a brief role in episode 19.
Episode 21: Windom Earle FINALLY shows up. They wasted too much time getting to this point.
Episode 22: The awful James subplot finally draws to a conclusion in what I consider to be hands-down the worst episode of the series. It's directed by Diane Keaton (yes, that Diane Keaton) and she shows no style, talent or ability behind the camera. She just tries to make things weird for the sake of being weird. Insert shots are horrible, the audio mix and dubbing are horrible... I really want to try and pretend that this episode doesn't exist. Sadly I can't dismiss it entirely because out of nowhere this episode remembers that Cooper was shot at the end of season one and it sets in motion the conclusion of that storyline. It also resolves the whole "Ben Horne goes mad" theme that was a lot of fun along the way.
Episode 23: This was the last episode before the show went on hiatus. It's also one of my favorites. It's a fantastic final episode for one of the series regulars and everything about it from the tone to the score music paints a picture of doom with the walls closing in quickly for said character. Ignore the last five seconds or so... whatever the hell they were thinking there just didn't translate.
Episode 24: The show returned to Thursday nights after I believe a two month gap, but the damage was already done. Still, we were lucky to get the series back on the air at all for six more episodes to conclude the season.
Michael Ontkean was very capable in his role as Sheriff Truman, however one thing he should have never, ever had to do was to act drunk and belligerent. He's terrible at it, and it makes those scenes in this episode fall flat. Heather Graham arrives as a love interest for Agent Cooper. She becomes a better actress later in her career.
This episode has the worst ending of any episode in the series. If they were hoping for renewed interest in the series after such a long break, this ending would not bring any casual viewers back the next week.
Episodes 25-28: Two main components of the Windom Earle storyline are completely shoved aside (one is actually literally shoved aside) as things ramp up to ridiculous speed with all sorts of new information being thrown at us left and right. To this day, there are details that I still don't understand. Killer monks are somehow involved now? What?
Episode 29: If there's one thing David Lynch seems to love, it's torturing us with old people. Both the two hour premiere and this one hour finale prominently feature really, really old people moving really, really slowly which in each case seems to suck away about 15 minutes of screen time.
If you're frustrated that this series finale offers no answers whatsoever, know that it was not filmed as a series finale but as the end of the season. There was still hope that the show would be renewed. But of course it was not.
Lynch then was given a second chance and was allowed to make a motion picture set within the Twin Peaks universe, but... well, that's another rant for another day.
The audio/video quality for the episodes in this DVD set is spectacular. Granted I'm basing that on comparing them to fuzzy LP tapes and equally fuzzy memories, but it's still a no-brainer that this is the best Twin Peaks has ever looked or sounded. If I was unaware of the show and was watching this for the first time today, I would not think it was as old as it is. There are no DTS audio tracks this time, but you get still get solid 5.1 mixes. And the Lynch/Frost logo at the end of each episode will still scare the crap out of you.
Every episode in the set includes the Log Lady intros from the show's Bravo run. These look nowhere near as clean as the episodes themselves, but they're good to have nonetheless. Unlike the previous set however, each episode does *not* include the "Previously on Twin Peaks" recap before each episode. Bummer.
Disc one includes an interview with Jennifer Lynch, you know who's daughter and author of The Secret Diary of Laura Palmer, a tie-in to the show that becomes a prominent piece of evidence in the murder investigation. It's a very interesting, relevant interview, however it is much too short for my tastes. She also refuses to mention a few details, as if there's still a binding non-disclosure pact for this 17 year old dead television series.
Disc two features an interview with series director Todd Holland. He praises shows like Lost for having the kind of patience with its storytelling that Twin Peaks used to have, and he discusses how the opening shot of his first episode in the second season came about. Again, good but too short.
Disc three's extra is an interview with director Caleb Deschanel. He discusses the brief flashback scene in episode 15 and how it came about. Interesting choice to focus on, considering everything that's going on in that episode...
Director/editor Duwayne Dunham is the fourth disc's participant. He gives some great insight into why he was the right choice to direct the first episode after the pilot.
Disc five sports an interview with episode 27 director Stephen Gyllenhaal. He mentions that there was one particular actor he had to work with that he just hated. I wonder who that was...
Disc six has an interview with director Tim Hunter. Also on the final disc is a 30+ minute collection of new interviews with performers Kyle MacLachlan, Sherilyn Fenn, Madchen Amick, Dana Ashbrook, Gary Hershberger, James Marshall, David Duchovny, Kimmy Robertson, Don Davis, Mary Jo Deschanel, Lenny Von Dohlen and Charlotte Stewart. These can be viewed individually or (thankfully) all at once.
While there are a great many key cast members missing (along with series creators Mark Frost and David Lynch), it's good to hear from some who've yet to have a voice in previous Peaks releases. David Duchovny and Lenny Von Dohlen for example. And unlike the interviews on the previous season and on the movie, these are all shot beautifully and professionally and are presented in anamorphic widescreen.
I know it sounds as though I have many complaints about this show, but the good still far outweighs the bad. Most of the worst moments here are still better than 99% of everything else that's ever been on television. From start to finish it remains my favorite television show of all time. And while the extras aren't as plentiful as they were in the first season set, at this point I'm just happy the thing got released at all.
Now if we could just get the pilot episode on DVD...